World Tasar Class Association
Minutes of the World Council Meeting held at the Ward Room, CFSA,
Esquimalt, BC, Canada, June 23, 2003 at 7 PM.
Present:
World Council Members
Name |
Region |
Status |
Cathy Sherwood |
North America |
President |
Chris Parkinson |
Australia |
Vice President & President, ATC |
Constantijn Udo |
Europe |
President, European Region |
Allan Johnson | North America | President, NATA |
George Motoyoshi |
Japan |
President, JTA |
Todd Blumel |
North America |
Chief Measurer |
Richard Spencer |
North America |
Executive Secretary |
Regrets
Name |
Region |
Status |
John Rischmiller | Europe | Immediate Past President |
Frank Bethwaite | Australia | Advisory Council |
Observers
Name |
Region |
|
David Bretherton | Australia | |
Rob Douglass | Australia | |
Graham Hanna | Australia | |
Sumiko Ishimaru | Japan | |
Elizabeth Kemmis | Australia | |
Beryl Parkinson | Australia | |
Helen Spencer | North Americ |
1. Introductions
Cathy Sherwood took the chair and introduced those present.
2. Minutes
The minutes of
the World Council meeting of August, 2001 as posted on the web,
were approved.
3. President's report. Cathy Sherwood
Cathy thanked all those present for attending. On behalf of
all competitors and others attending the World Championship, she
then thanked the Vancouver Island Tasar fleet and the many helpers
and volunteers for organising and running an outstanding
event.
4. Regional reports
Europe. Constantijn Udo reported that there is some Tasar
activity in Holland, Germany, Italy and Switzerland, with about 8
to 10 active boats. The number of other classes, and spread
of Tasar activity over a relatively large area, makes it very
difficult to increase the numbers of active Tasars in Continental
Europe
UK District. Liz Grist, President of TAUK, submitted a written
report.
Australia. Chris Parkinson reported that Tasar activity in
Australia is holding steady. Very few new boats are being
sold, but demand is high for second hand boats, with prices rangind
from $2,000 to $10,000 AUD. Activity is strongest in NSW and
Victoria. There are 2 active clubs in Western Australia, plus
one in Kimberly. The 2002 Australian Nationals, held in Port
Lincoln, South Australia, attracted 50 boats and were a great
event. Tasar activity in Queensland has declined in Cairns,
but is starting up in Brisbane. There is a strong fleet in
Darwin, NT, including a number of younger sailors.
There are about 250 members of the Australian Tasar Council.
There is a website at www.tasar.org.au, with a forum for posting
messages. The newsletter is being distributed in pdf form,
via email.
Frank Bethwaite's proposal for a Tasar II made the class in
Australia think about the future of the class. There is now
more interest in having the class market and promote the boat,
rather than relying on the builder to do this. A website for
registering boats is being considered, with the intention of
recording boat number, name of current owner and name of sailing
club. A Tasar reunion could follow.
The ATC is proposing a Technical Committee (see agenda item
8).
The ATC considers that voting on the minimum hull weight after
every World championship, as required by class rule D.3.2,
is disruptive to the class, and creates a sense of instability in
the rules. We should not hold another vote until we think it is
likely to be successful.
North America. Allan Johnson reported that most North
American Tasar activity is in the Pacific North West, particularly
in Vancouver, Seattle and Portland. There is also a fleet in
Edmonton. The Victoria Worlds were very helpful in increasing
activity in Seattle, and they are getting 12 to 15 boats racing on
Thursday evenings. There are boats at the Worlds from
Alberta, San Diego and Bellingham. We do know of active boats
in other parts of the region, including 2 in Annapolis.
College sailors are joining the Tasar class, and NATA membership is
currently about 45.
In Vancouver, clinics given by Thilo Giese have been very popular,
and the fleet is positive about maintaining or increasing its
size.
Japan. George Motoyoshi reported that the Japanese Tasar
Association is strong, with 46 boats competing in their 2002
nationals. They hope to get more younger sailors
involved. JTA have discussed the crew weight rule C.6 at
length, and would like to see it removed. They ask that the
World Council continue to discuss either modifying or removing this
rule.
5. Executive Secretary's report. Richard Spencer
thanked the regions for contributing to the purchase new trophies,
and thanked Carol Buchan for purchasing these. He reported
that there is currently 6.97 GBP in the WTCA bank account.
There will be consultation with World Council members about how to
split costs between regions before any future amounts are levied
for special purposes. The preferred method is to split costs based
on membership.
Hull weight: Voting on the proposal from the 2001 World
Council Meeting to reduce the minimum hull weight was 7 opposed and
3 in favour. Todd reported that the average hull weight for
37 boats weighed in North America was 147 lbs (66.7 kg). The
average weight went up slightly when older boats were sailed in
preparation for the Worlds.
Moved Richard Spencer, seconded David Bretherton, the World
Council should not propose a reduction in minimum hull weight at
this time. Carried
Crew weight. Richard proposed we trial a revised crew weight
rule, along the lines proposed by Frank Bethwaite (see "Crew
Weight"). Frank suggested that only three quarters of the
difference between the crew weight and 130 kg should be carried (to
a maximum of 12 kg). Frank also discussed his ideas on crew
weight in an earlier article on "Performance
Equalization for smaller stature crews".
NATA does not enforce the crew weight rule. NATA agrees that this
changes the results in some conditions, and also has some affect on
who chooses to join the fleet, and who leaves it .In NATA's view
this is not unfair - it is just different.
George said that many crews in Japan have to carry the maximum 12
kg of ballast when the crew weight rule applies. Japan normally
enforces the crew weight rule. They have tried racing without
crew weight, and believes there is no difference in regatta
results. Richard pointed out that the members in any region
can vote not to use the crew weight rule in regional events,
although it will be applied in World Championships.
Chris said that equalization, and the requirement to carry weight,
is not an issue in Australia. All underweight crews carry
weight in all Tasar events. There would be strong opposition
to eliminating the requirement for equalization ballast.
Agreed: Chris Parkinson agreed to recommend to districts in
Australia that they trial a requirement for carrying 50% of the
difference between crew weight and 130 kg and report on the
results.
Requirements for World Championships. The draft requirements,
which were posted on the
web, were ammended to read (in the section: "Agreement of the
MNA"): "Organizers should contact their MNA immediately following
approval of the site by the World Council to get the MNA's
agreement to the proposed venue, dates and organizing club." Moved
Richard Spencer, seconded Tijn Udo, that we adopt the proposed
requirements, as ammended. Carried.
ISAF Report. The requirements for the report to be submitted to
ISAF, following a World Championship, as part of the class annual
report to ISAF, are on the web, and were presented for
information.
Website: The World Tasar Class and NATA website is the
primary vehicle for informing members about Tasar news and
developments.
6. Designer's Report. Frank
Bethwaite's report was distributed at the meeting. Frank
was thanked for his many contributions over the years, and his
continuing interest in and support of the class.
7. Measurer's report. Todd Blumel. Todd is
resigning after serving as Chief Measurer since 2001.
Measurer's sub-committee. Moved Todd Blumel, seconded Tijn
Udo, that there be a Measurer's sub-committee, with a
representative from each region chosen by the Chief Measurer, to
assist the Chief Measurer at each Worlds. Carried.
Items from the measurer's meeting: (a) Measurers' Guidebook.
It would be helpful if there was a guidebook for measurers. This
should be available on the website. Tony Keevers has a guide
for people buying a used Tasar, and there is a guide for people who
build kit boats in Australia. These could provide material
that could be included in a measurers' guide.
(b) Hounds to deck measurement. The measurers recommend
reinstatement of a hounds to deck measurement. Moved Todd Blumel,
seconded David Bretherton, that we propose a rule requiring the top
mast be supported on an insert (as on current Australian and North
American Tasars) and a minimum measurement of 3720 mm from hounds
to deck. Carried.
(c) Forestay and shroud adjustment. Some competitors are
adjusting their shrouds and forestays on the water between
races. This is considered to be potentially unsafe, as it can
lead to dismasting. Moved Todd Blumel, seconded Chris Parkinson,
that we propose a rule prohibiting the adjustment of forestay
and/or shrouds on the water. Carried.
(d) Modified shroud pull backs. Unless the shrouds are
pulled back from a position directly aft of the slide, and close to
the deck, the purchase is less than 2:1. Moved Richard Spencer,
seconded David Bretherton, that we propose a rule change to allow a
turning block aft of the slide to ensure the purchase is always
2:1. There should be a limit on the length of the pull back
line. Carried.
(e) Length of mainsheet strop. Moved Todd Blumel, seconded
Dave Bretherton, that we propose changing rule C.2.3.(d)
to eliminate the maximum length measurement for the mainsheet
strop, and require only a minimum length of 240 mm.
Carried.
Interpretations. Moved Todd Blumel, seconded Dave Bretherton, that
interpretation 31 be
approved. Carried. Moved Todd Blumel, seconded Allan Johnson,
that interpretation 32 be
approved. Carried. Moved Todd Blumel, seconded Allan Johnson,
that interpretation 33 be
approved. There was considerable discussion of this
item. Dave Bretherton said that he considers it is unsafe to
remove the shroud stop in the heavy conditions that prevail in
Australia, because the plastic end fitting cannot be relied on to
stop the slide coming out of the track. Todd reported that Frank
has agreed that shroud stops can be removed without compromising
the design. Carried.
Appreciation. Todd Blumel was thanked for doing an excellent job
as Chief Measurer.
8. Proposal from ATC for a Technical Development
Committee. Moved Chris Parkinson, seconded Todd Blumel, that
we establish a Technical Development committee as proposed by the
ATC, with a chair appointed by the World Council and members from
each region. The committee should have the authority to trial
developments and report back to the World Council with
recommendations. Carried. Moved Richard Spencer, seconded
Todd Blumel, that with the approval of the World Council, special
dues may be levied from the regions, as required, to pay for
developments, experiments, trials, etc. Carried.
9. Sites for next World Championships. Chris Parkinson
proposed Darwin, NT, Australia as the site of the next worlds, in
July or August, 2005. Approved.
The Darwin Worlds will be followed by: 2007 - Japan or Europe 2009
- Europe or Japan The normal sequence would have the 2007 Worlds in
Japan. Europe will hold the Worlds in 2007 if Japan is
willing to delay holding a Worlds until 2009. JTA will advise
the World Council of their plans.
10. Other business. None
11. Election of Officers. The following were elected:
President - Chris Parkinson, President, ATC Vice President - George
Motoyoshi, President, JTA Measurer - Dave Bretherton, NATA
Executive Secretary - Richard Spencer, NATA
The World Council thanked Cathy Sherwood for doing an outstanding
job as President, and Todd Blumel for his great work, both as Chief
Measurer, and as co-chair of the World's organizing committee.