Dynamic Response
Mast and topmast Springiness.
The wind is never steady. Wind stronger than 6kts becomes a
turbulent boundary layer and is always unsteady in the "fine grain"
frequency range, ie. with a puff or lull every few seconds. This
causes a sail on a springy mast to flex in constant motion around
its static shape, particularly at the leech. If a mast is too stiff
the boat will handle "woodenly" and sail slowly. As the mast is
made more flexible the handling becomes more pleasant and speed
increases. Beyond the optimum the mast yields to the gusts too
easily and the rig loses power, handling becomes mushy and the boat
sails more slowly.
The design flexibility of the Tasar mast/topmast is a rate of
spring of 5.5lbs/in in the stiff direction, and 2.8lbs/in in the
sideways direction. A simple way to check this is to put the boat
on its side, put a support such as the back of a chair under the
mast exactly at the height of the forestay shackle-pin, slacken the
shrouds, spring the top diamond stay out of the spreader, and hang
a weight from the tip of the topmast first with the major axis
vertical, then with the major axis horizontal. Measure the height
of the tip above the ground both unloaded and loaded. The
difference is the deflection.
Example: I have just measured a stock mast and topmast. I clamped
the butt to a bench, put a fulcrum under the extreme top of the
lower mast (this is the design height of the hounds shackle-pin
hole) slipped in a new topmast with sleeve and stiffener, and used
a 30lb weight to load the tip. "F" means "fore and aft" ie. long
dimension vertical in this test. "X" means "cross ship" ie. long
dimension horizontal.
F
X
Height of tip unloaded
30.5 30.7ins
Height of tip loaded
25.0 19.9
Deflection (1 -
2)
5.5 10.8
Rate of spring:
30/5.5=5.45lbs/in
30/10.8=2.8lbs/in
Note. Do not be too surprised if your figures are different. There
are some strange animals out there. In the discussion about topmast
stiffeners, somebody quoted a topmast much heavier than design.
Where did that one (those ones) come from? Heavier sections will
necessarily be far too stiff, and slow. I understand that one
pressing long ago was from soft alloy. (I didn't ear of that for
years).
Dynamic Operation
To understand how the rig is designed to work for you, let us
follow a crew who start sailing to windward in say 7kts, with the
wind speed varying every few seconds between 6kts and 8kts
Settings -
Downhaul - No diagonal wrinkles
Rotation - 45 degrees
Outhaul - Closer to 1 than 2
Vang - Slack
Angles - (jib) Right in
Steer for both lower jib tufts streaming.
Tension mainsheet for upper leech ribbons "just popping in and
out".
Trim traveller so boom is along centreline in 6kt lulls.
Sheet jib for upper windward tuft just breaking occasionally.
Let us assume that the wind surges to say 10kts, with puffs to 11
and lulls to 9kts.
Tighten the outhaul to about two dots. This will eliminate backwind
from the jib.
It will be necessary to tighten the mainsheet to hold the upper
leech in. If you don't, the upper leech ribbons will stream all the
time, and that is slow. As you tighten the sheet, three things will
happen. The topmast will bend back a bit, which flattens the upper
mainsail to match your flattening of the lower mainsail with the
outhaul. Diagonal wrinkles will appear downwards from the batten
protectors.
Tighten the downhaul to eliminate them. This preserves mainsail
shape. The forestay will become tighter, which flattens the jib to
match your flattening of the mainsail. Note that the action of
tightening the mainsheet has automatically flattened both the upper
mainsail and the jib.
Trim jibsheet as before for upper windward tufts to stream with
occasional break.
Now for the important bit.
By this time you will be hiking with say 70% total effort. If you
look at your leech, it should be "shimmering" all the time with a
movement of say plus and minus half an inch. The apparent wind in
the brief lulls will be about 13kts, and 15 in the puffs. The
heeling force will vary as the square of the apparent wind speed,
so the difference between puff and lull will be about 33%.
To keep the boat steady and upright you will need to play the
traveller for quick control as you move your bodies smoothly for
coordinated control. As the traveller car moves to leeward, the
design of the sheet system and the curve of the traveller track is
such that the strop tension remains constant and the leech tension
and forestay tension do not change, so the upper mainsail and the
jib stay flat in the puff. This is fast and is the way the rig is
designed to work.
Note. If you rig your traveller with the blocks high and the strop
low, the tension will ease as the traveller car goes out. This way
the upper mainsail and the jib will go fuller in each puff. This is
not as fast.
In Stronger Winds
Let us assume that the wind increases further to about 13kts, with
puffs to 15 and lull to 11kts. The critical change here is that the
wind is now stronger than the design wind (which is about 12kts for
the average crew.) At the design wind your whole object
changes.
In winds lighter than the design wind the object has been to
extract the maximum possible "power" without too much drag.
Technically, the fastest trim is that which gives the greatest
"power factor"; in the case if a glider this is the speed and flap
setting which gives the lowest sinking speed. In winds stronger
than the design wind, only one thing matters - minimum aerodynamic
drag. This is the glider looking for greatest distance, which is
achieved by flying absolutely clean and substantially faster than
the speed for minimum sink.
As soon as you have more "power" than you can use - as soon as the
heeling force is more than you can hold up without easing the sails
- you are in the strong wind regime. Immediately flatten to
extreme. Stay slides come right back to tighten the forestay and so
flatten the jib. Outhaul is pulled tight (to 3 dots) to flatten the
lower mainsail. In stronger winds the designed rig springiness
gives you options with the upper mainsail.
In winds which are relatively smooth, you will sail fastest and
point highest with a reasonably tight sheet and sufficient vang to
flatten the upper mainsail.
In rough winds any tight sheet will cause the boat to stagger with
each gust onslaught. You will sail faster with a slacker sheet and
the traveller to windward and a much tighter vang. This will make
the upper leech "springy". Set like this it will absorb the gust
onslaughts by yielding elastically and driving the boat forward
rather than pushing it over.
To sum up
In winds less than the design wind, if you trim to keep the upper
leech ribbons just popping in and out, the mainsheet tension will
automatically flatten the upper mainsail and jib to the fastest
fullness. In stronger winds, you can alter the elasticity to match
the roughness. This is how the rig was designed to work. Give
factory settings a go - you too might win gold.
Frank Bethwaite